Making Better Decisions: The Values Filter That Cuts Through Complexity
Your analysis is thorough. Your options are well-defined. Your criteria are clear. And you're still paralyzed or worse, making decisions you regret almost immediately after making them.
Here's what's missing: The Values Decision Filter. It adds the dimension that analysis alone can't provide alignment with what actually matters and reveals why some logically correct decisions still feel wrong.
The Analysis Trap
Decision-making research shows that more analysis doesn't always produce better decisions. At some point, additional data creates confusion rather than clarity. The important factors get buried in the unimportant ones.
The assumption behind analysis-heavy decision-making is that decisions are primarily cognitive: gather enough information, weigh it correctly, and the answer emerges.
But decisions involve the whole person, including values. A decision that's analytically optimal but values-misaligned feels wrong and often is wrong, because the analysis missed what actually mattered.
Why Decisions Feel Wrong
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we examine decisions that felt wrong in hindsight, values misalignment is consistently present.
The decision violated Personal Responsibility. You chose something that didn't align with who you feel responsible for being.
The decision threatened Security it created uncertainty you weren't emotionally prepared for.
The decision compromised Relationships; it damaged connections that mattered more than you realized.
The decision conflicted with Loyalty, it betrayed commitments you'd made to others or yourself.
Analysis didn't catch these factors because they're not analytical. They're values-based. And values require a different kind of consideration.
The Values Decision Filter
Five questions to ask before any significant decision:
1. Which values does each option serve?
Before weighing options analytically, identify which values are in play.
Option A might serve Financial Security but threaten Relationships.
Option B might serve Personal Growth, but create Security uncertainty.
Option C might serve Family, but compromise Career advancement.
Map the values explicitly. What does each option provide? What does it cost?
This isn't analysis. It's values awareness. The factors that will determine whether the decision feels right or wrong become visible.
2. Which values are non-negotiable?
Some values can be traded off. Others can't, at least not for you.
If Family is non-negotiable, no amount of Career advancement compensates for Family sacrifice.
If Integrity is non-negotiable, no efficiency gain justifies ethical compromise.
If Relationships are non-negotiable, no financial benefit is worth relational damage.
Know your non-negotiables before the decision pressure arrives. When you know them, decisions that violate them become obvious regardless of how analytically optimal they appear.
3. What would the person I want to be decide?
Decisions shape identity. Each choice moves you toward or away from who you want to become.
Project forward: "If I choose this, what does it say about who I am? Is that who I want to be?"
Sometimes the "right" analytical choice isn't the choice that the person you want to be would make. The values filter catches this where analysis doesn't.
4. Who will this decision affect, and what do they value?
Decisions don't happen in isolation. They affect others' families, colleagues, customers, and communities.
Consider: "What do the affected people value? How does each option serve or threaten their values?"
Decisions that feel right in isolation can feel wrong when the full impact on others becomes clear. The values filter surfaces these impacts before the decision, not after.
5. When I look back on this decision in five years, which values will I wish I had prioritized?
Immediate analysis favors immediate factors. Value consideration spans time.
Project forward: "From the perspective of five-year-older me, what will I wish I had prioritized? What will seem important? What will seem trivial?"
Regret typically comes from values misalignment, not analytical errors. The five-year test surfaces what will actually matter.
Applying the Filter
The Values Decision Filter doesn't replace analysis. It complements it.
Process:
1. Do the analysis. Understand the options, the trade-offs, and the likely outcomes.
2. Apply the values filter. Map which values each option serves and threatens.
3. Check for non-negotiables. Does any option violate values that can't be compromised?
4. Consider identity. What would the person you want to be choose?
5. Consider impact. How does each option affect others and their values?
6. Apply the time test. What will matter in five years?
The combination of analysis and values consideration produces decisions that are both logically sound and emotionally aligned.
When Values Conflict
Sometimes the hard decisions are hard because values conflict with each other.
Family versus Career. Security versus Growth. Loyalty versus Integrity.
When values conflict:
- Acknowledge the conflict explicitly.
- Identify which value ranks higher for you in this context.
- Accept that the decision will cost something, and choose which cost you can live with.
- Don't pretend you can have it all when you can't.
Values conflicts don't have perfect answers. They have the least-bad answers. The goal isn't a decision that serves all values, it's a decision that serves the most important values while honestly accepting the cost.
The Strategic Question
Before your next significant decision, ask this: If I ignore the analysis completely and just ask what my values say, what would the answer be?
If the values answer and the analysis answer align, you have a clear decision.
If they conflict, you have more work to do understanding why they conflict and which should guide you.
Analysis tells you what you can do. Values tell you what you should do.
The best decisions honor both.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
