Leading Real Estate Teams: The Values Approach That Keeps Top Performers
Your brokerage offers competitive splits. Your technology is current. Your brand has recognition. And your best agents keep leaving, sometimes for competitors with worse offerings, sometimes for independence, and sometimes for reasons they can't quite articulate.
Here's what the departures are really about: The Real Estate Values Leadership Model. It shows that agents stay for values alignment, not splits, and that leading real estate teams requires understanding what makes independent spirits feel both free and connected.
The Independence Paradox
Real estate industry research shows high agent mobility and chronic retention challenges. The easy explanation is economic agents follow the money.
But that explanation fails to account for agents who leave higher-earning positions for lower ones, or who value team membership over maximum income, or who stay in clearly suboptimal situations because something else is working.
Real estate agents are fundamentally independent operators who choose a career with autonomy at its core. Leading them requires understanding this identity and providing something they can't create for themselves.
What Real Estate Agents Value
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we profile successful real estate agents, certain values appear consistently.
Autonomy (ranked 11th at 40%) is fundamental. People who choose real estate choose it, often specifically, for independence. They want to run their own business, make their own decisions, and control their own time.
Financial Security (ranked 3rd at 68%) creates motivation but also anxiety. The feast-or-famine nature of real estate creates chronic security concerns that agents manage differently based on their values profile.
Relationships (ranked 2nd at 79%) are central to success. Agents who thrive do so through relationships with clients, referral sources, and colleagues. The work is relational.
Personal Growth (ranked 6th at 51%) drives high performers. They want to get better, learn more, and develop capabilities. Stagnation pushes them elsewhere.
Belonging (ranked 4th at 56%) might seem to conflict with autonomy, but it doesn't. Agents want independence in how they work. They also want to be part of something, a team, a brand, or a community.
The Real Estate Values Leadership Model
Four leadership practices that retain top performers:
Practice 1: Protect Autonomy While Creating Value
The fundamental challenge: agents chose independence but affiliated for a reason. Leadership must respect independence while providing value that justifies affiliation.
Protect autonomy through:
- Making as much structure optional as possible
- Explaining the "why" when structure is required
- Creating value that agents choose rather than mandating participation
- Trusting agents to run their practices their way
The question to ask is, "Is this requirement necessary for value creation, or is it control disguised as value?"
Agents resent unnecessary control. They appreciate genuine value. The distinction determines retention.
Practice 2: Create Belonging That Independent Spirits Want
Belonging and autonomy aren't opposites. Agents can feel part of something while maintaining independence if the belonging is structured correctly.
Create belonging through:
- A community that doesn't require attendance mandates
- Shared identity that agents choose to adopt
- Support structures that help without constraining
- Celebrations of collective success that honor individual achievement
The question to ask is, "Would agents describe themselves as part of this team or as affiliated independents?"
The answer reveals whether belonging exists or is just assumed.
Practice 3: Address Financial Security without Creating Dependence
The income volatility of real estate creates security anxiety. Leadership can address this issue without undermining the independence that agents value.
Address security through:
- Income smoothing options for agents who want them
- Business development support during slow periods
- Financial planning resources
- Creating predictability where possible without guarantees
Ask yourself: "Do my agents feel supported for their financial future here, or just for their financial present?"
Security-anxious agents leave at the first sign of uncertainty. Security-confident agents stay through market cycles.
Practice 4: Invest in Personal Growth genuinely.
Top performers want to improve. Organizations that assist employees in their improvement earn loyalty that cannot be achieved through other means.
Invest in growth through:
- Development beyond compliance training
- Coaching and mentorship structures
- Advanced skill-building opportunities
- Career pathing for agents who want it
The question to ask is, "Is the average agent at my brokerage measurably better than they were a year ago?"
If the answer is yes, you're creating value that's hard to leave. If not, you're offering affiliation without development, which independence easily replaces.
The Leadership Balance
Leading real estate teams requires balancing seemingly contradictory values.
Autonomy and Belonging: Create community without constraining freedom.
Financial Security and Independence: Support stability without creating dependence.
Personal Growth and Self-Direction: Invest in development while respecting agent choices.
The leaders who get this balance right retain agents in an industry known for churn.
The balance isn't a formula. It's sensitivity to what each agent actually needs, which varies by their individual values profile.
The Departure Conversation
When agents leave, the real reason rarely appears in the exit conversation. "Better opportunity" is safe to say. "I didn't feel supported," "I felt controlled," or "I wasn't growing" are harder.
Listen between the lines. Track patterns across departures. The consistent themes reveal which values your leadership is failing to serve.
Then fix those not with programs, but with genuine attention to what agents actually need.
The Strategic Question
Before your next retention initiative, ask this: What am I providing that agents can't create for themselves?
If the answer is just "brand and splits," you're competing on commodities.
If the answer includes "belonging without control, security without dependence, and growth without constraint," you're offering something worth staying for.
Real estate agents stay where their values are served.
Serve them, and the retention challenges diminish.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
