Why Succession Planning Fails: The Values Alignment Nobody Considers
Your succession plan identifies high-potential leaders. Your development pipeline is full. Your competency assessments are sophisticated. And when transitions happen, they still go badly, not because successors lack capability, but because something essential was missed.
Here's what succession planning typically ignores: The Values Succession Framework. It reveals that capability isn't the primary predictor of succession success. Values alignment is. Successors who don't share the values of the role, the team, and the organization fail regardless of how capable they are.
The Capability Trap
Leadership succession research shows that most organizations focus succession planning on identifying and developing capability. Leadership competencies. Technical skills. Strategic thinking.
But succession failures rarely come from capability gaps. The new leader knows how to lead. They just lead in ways that don't fit the culture, the team, or the role's requirements.
The fit issue is values. When a successor's values align with what the role and organization need, capability expresses itself appropriately. When values misalign, capability is deployed in ways that create friction.
What Values Alignment Means in Succession
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we examine successful and failed successions, values patterns become clear.
Alignment with role values: Different roles require different values. A CFO role might require strong Financial Security values. A CHRO role might require strong Relationships and Belonging values. A CCO role might require strong Service to Others values. Successors whose values don't match role requirements struggle.
Alignment with team values: Leaders inherit teams with existing values profiles. A leader whose values conflict with the team's values creates friction that the team can't overcome.
Alignment with organizational values: Organizations have cultures built on values. Leaders whose personal values contradict organizational values either fail to integrate or change the culture, sometimes destructively.
The Values Succession Framework
Five dimensions to assess in succession planning:
1. Role values requirements
Every leadership role has values requirements beyond competency requirements.
A sales leadership role requires values that drive competition and achievement, but also relationships if the sales culture is relational.
An operations leadership role requires values that drive efficiency and reliability, but also flexibility if the environment is volatile.
A people leadership role requires values that drive care and development, but also accountability if performance management is critical.
Assessment question: "What values does this role require, beyond the capabilities it requires?"
Map the role's values and requirements explicitly. Then assess whether candidates' values profiles align.
2. Team values compatibility
Successors inherit teams. Those teams have values collective profiles that determine what kind of leadership they respond to.
A team high in Autonomy needs a leader who values autonomy and provides it.
A team high in Security needs a leader who values stability and creates it.
A team high in Personal Growth needs a leader who invests in development.
Assessment question: "What values does this team have, and what kind of leader will they follow?"
The capable leader whose values conflict with the team's values will struggle to gain followership. Values compatibility predicts success.
3. Organizational culture alignment
Organizations have values embedded in their culture regardless of what's stated on walls.
Assessment question: "What values actually drive behavior in this organization, and does the successor share them?"
A successor from outside who brings values that conflict with organizational reality faces an uphill battle. They either adapt (losing authenticity) or conflict (creating friction).
A successor from inside who shares organizational values integrates smoothly. The challenge is whether those values should continue or need to evolve.
4. Transition values sensitivity
Transitions are sensitive moments. The values threatened during transition determine whether the transition succeeds.
Teams feel uncertainty (Security threatened). They wonder about belonging (Belonging threatened). They assess whether they'll be respected (Respect threatened).
Assessment question: "How will the successor handle the values sensitivities of transition?"
Successors high in Relationships navigate transitions better because they prioritize connection during uncertain times.
Successors high in Security themselves may become defensive during transition stress, which teams experience negatively.
5. Future values requirements
Succession planning should anticipate future needs, not just current ones.
Assessment question: "What values will this role require as the organization evolves?"
If the organization is moving toward more innovation, successors with strong Creativity and Personal Growth values are better positioned.
If the organization is moving toward more stability, successors with strong Security and Reliability values are better positioned.
Future values alignment matters as much as current alignment.
Assessing Values in Candidates
Values are harder to assess than capabilities, but not impossible.
Behavioral interview questions:
- "Tell me about a decision where your values were tested. What did you do?" (Reveals which values matter most)
- "Describe a time when you disagreed with organizational direction because of what you believed." (Reveals values strength)
- "What kind of team do you work best with? What kind do you struggle with?" (Reveals team values compatibility)
Reference conversations:
- "What does this person care most deeply about?" (Reveals core values)
- "What kind of people did they build the strongest relationships with?" (Reveals values compatibility patterns)
- "What made them frustrated or energized?" (Reveals values triggers)
Extended observation:
- Behavior over time reveals values more reliably than interviews.
- Watch what candidates do when values are tested.
- Notice what they celebrate and what they question.
The Strategic Question
Before your next succession decision, ask this: Does this candidate share the values that this role, team, and organization require?
If values align, capability has room to express itself appropriately.
If values misalign, capability will be deployed in ways that create friction with the role requirements, with the team, or with the organization.
Capability is necessary. Values alignment determines whether capability creates success.
Assess both. Weigh both. Decide based on both.
That's succession planning that actually works.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
