Why Your Customer Experience Strategy Isn't Working: The Values Disconnect
Your customer journey is mapped. Your touchpoints are optimized. Your NPS is tracked religiously. And somehow, customers still leave for competitors and rarely advocate for you.
Here's what's missing: The Values-Based CX Audit. It evaluates whether your experience actually delivers what customers value or whether you've optimized for metrics that have nothing to do with what creates loyalty.
The Optimization Trap
Forrester Research shows that despite massive investment in customer experience, customer perceptions of CX quality have stagnated. Companies are spending more on experience and getting flat results.
The problem is what gets optimized. Speed. Efficiency. First-call resolution. These metrics are easy to measure. So organizations improve them.
But customers don't experience metrics. They experience whether they feel valued, understood, and cared for. And those feelings don't correlate neatly with operational efficiency.
What Customers Actually Experience
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we examine what creates memorable customer experiences, the findings diverge from typical CX metrics.
Respect (ranked 8th at 48%) determines whether an interaction feels positive or negative. Efficient interactions can still feel disrespectful. Slow interactions can still feel deeply respectful.
Relationships (ranked 2nd at 79%) create loyalty that efficiency never touches. Do customers feel they have a relationship with your organization, or do they feel processed by it?
Security (ranked 20th at 28%) affects how customers feel about issues and problems. Do they feel you'll take care of them? That they're safe with you?
Trustworthiness (ranked 19th at 28%) accumulates over interactions. Every touchpoint either builds or erodes trust. Consistency matters more than optimization.
The Values-Based CX Audit
Evaluate every touchpoint against these four questions:
1. Does this touchpoint communicate Respect?
Test: How does a customer describe how they felt during this interaction?
Respect isn't about courtesy scripts. It's about whether the customer felt treated as a valued individual or processed as a transaction.
Red flags: Scripts that sound scripted. Time pressure that customers can feel. Policies recited instead of solutions offered. Any moment where the customer feels like an inconvenience.
The standard: After every interaction, could the customer honestly say, "They respected my time, my intelligence, and my needs"?
2. Does this touchpoint build or damage the Relationship?
Test: Is this interaction bringing the customer closer to your organization or pushing them away?
Every touchpoint creates movement toward connection or toward distance. Positive interactions build relationship equity. Negative interactions spend it.
Red flags: Interactions where customers feel unknown. Requests to repeat information already provided. Handoffs that feel like starting over. Any moment where the customer feels like a stranger.
The standard: After every interaction, could the customer honestly say, "They know me better now than before"?
3. Does this touchpoint increase or decrease felt Security?
Test: Does the customer feel more confident or less confident about their relationship with you?
Security is felt as "they've got me." Uncertainty, confusion, and unresolved issues erode security.
Red flags: Promised callbacks that don't happen. Issues that require multiple contacts. Vague responses to specific concerns. Any moment where the customer doesn't know what happens next.
The standard: After every interaction, could the customer honestly say, "I feel confident they'll take care of me"?
4. Does this touchpoint build or erode Trust?
Test: Is trust higher or lower after this interaction than before?
Trust accumulates through consistency and erodes through inconsistency. One broken promise can undo dozens of kept ones.
Red flags: Saying one thing and doing another. Policies that benefit the company at the customer's expense. Any gap between stated values and actual experience.
The standard: After every interaction, could the customer honestly say, "I trust them more now"?
The Metrics That Actually Matter
If you're measuring the wrong things, you're optimizing the wrong things.
Instead of speed, measure perceived respect. Did the customer feel valued during the interaction, regardless of duration?
Instead of the resolution rate, measure relationship strength. Does the customer feel more connected to you after the interaction?
Instead of an effort score, measure security. Does the customer feel more confident about their relationship with you?
Instead of satisfaction, measure trust trajectory. Is trust building over time?
These are harder to measure. They're also what actually determines loyalty.
Redesigning for Values
When you audit touchpoints through values, redesign opportunities emerge.
The efficient process that feels disrespectful should be redesigned not for efficiency, but for respect. Add a moment of acknowledgment. Remove the time pressure. Change the language from transactional to relational.
The handoff that damages relationships should be redesigned. Make sure the next person knows what the previous person learned. Don't make customers repeat themselves.
The uncertainty that erodes security should be resolved. Tell customers exactly what happens next. Follow up before they have to follow up.
The inconsistency that destroys trust should be eliminated. Make promises carefully and keep them obsessively.
The Strategic Question
Here's what I ask organizations evaluating their customer experience: Are you optimizing for what you can measure or for what customers actually value?
The things you can measure, speed, resolution, and satisfaction scores, are proxies. They correlate imperfectly with what creates loyal customers.
The things that create loyalty, respect, relationships, security, and trust are harder to measure. But they're what customers actually experience.
Measure the proxies if you must. But design for values.
That's the difference between good metrics and a great experience.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
