Culture Isn't Built in Workshops: The Values Foundation Nobody Talks About
You've done the culture work. You identified your values. You rolled out the posters. You trained the managers. And somehow, the culture feels exactly the same—or worse, now it feels hollow because the gap between stated and lived culture is more visible than ever.
Here's the problem: The Values-Based Culture Architecture. It shows that culture isn't created through declaration. It's created through alignment between stated values and organizational systems. Mismatch is what makes culture initiatives fail.
Why Culture Initiatives Fail
Research on culture change shows that most culture initiatives fail to create meaningful change. Organizations invest in values, work, communication, and training. Behaviors don't shift.
The assumption behind most cultural work is that culture is about beliefs, and beliefs can be changed through communication and training.
But culture isn't beliefs. Culture is "how things actually work around here." It's shaped by systems, incentives, structures, and consequences, not by posters or workshops.
When stated values conflict with system realities, systems always win.
What Culture Actually Is
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we examine organizational culture, it becomes clear that culture is the collective expression of which values are actually rewarded and which are actually punished.
What gets promoted? (Reveals valued behaviors)
What gets punished? (Reveals unacceptable behaviors)
What gets ignored? (Reveals irrelevant values regardless of what's stated)
What's rewarded informally? (Reveals true culture beyond policy)
Culture statements say "we value innovation." But if the organization promotes careful people and punishes failed experiments, the actual culture values caution regardless of what's stated.
The Values-Based Culture Architecture
Four elements that create real culture:
Element 1: Systems alignment
Every organizational system communicates values. Compensation systems, performance systems, hiring systems, and promotion systems each tell people what's actually valued.
Culture alignment questions:
- Does our compensation system reward the behaviors our culture values?
- Does our performance system measure what our stated values require?
- Do we hire people whose values match our stated culture?
- Do we promote people who embody our stated values?
If any system contradicts stated values, employees notice. They learn the real culture from the systems, not from the posters.
To build culture, align systems with stated values. If you value collaboration but reward individual achievement, fix the reward system. If you value innovation but punish failure, fix the consequence system.
Element 2: Leadership behavior
Leaders are culture carriers. What leaders do communicates what's actually valued far more than what's stated.
Culture alignment questions:
- Do leaders behave consistently with stated values?
- What happens when leaders violate stated values?
- Do senior leaders receive the same consequences as junior employees?
- Would employees say that leaders embody the values or just talk about them?
A single leader publicly violating stated values without consequence destroys cultural credibility instantly. "The values don't apply to important people" becomes the actual culture.
To build culture, hold leaders accountable to values first. Visible accountability creates credibility. Visible inconsistency destroys it.
Element 3: Story creation
Cultures are transmitted through stories. "Remember when..." stories tell new employees what actually happens here.
Culture alignment questions:
- What stories do employees tell each other about "how things work here"?
- Do those stories align with stated values, or contradict them?
- Are there stories about people being rewarded for values-consistent behavior?
- Are there stories about people being punished for values violations (especially at senior levels)?
If the stories contradict the values, the stories are the culture.
To build culture, create stories intentionally. Publicly recognize values-consistent behavior. Publicly address values violations. Create the stories that transmit the culture you want.
Element 4: Experience consistency
Culture is experienced daily in thousands of small interactions. Each interaction either reinforces or undermines stated values.
Culture alignment questions:
- Do daily experiences align with stated values?
- Is the employee experience consistent with what's claimed?
- Do customers experience the values we claim?
- Are there parts of the organization where values don't apply?
Stated values that disappear under pressure aren't values; they're aspirations. Culture is what happens when things are difficult, not when things are easy.
To build culture, examine daily experience. Where do stated values break down? What pressures cause inconsistency? Fix the breakdown points.
Why Posters Don't Work
Posting values on walls doesn't create culture. It creates awareness of stated values, which might or might not match the actual culture.
When stated values match actual culture, posters reinforce what people already experience. They're fine.
When stated values contradict actual culture, posters create cynicism. Every employee who sees the poster while experiencing the opposite becomes more disengaged.
Posters follow culture. They don't create it.
Building Culture Through Systems
Culture change requires systems change.
If you want a culture of innovation, build systems that reward risk-taking and don't punish failure.
If you want a culture of collaboration, build incentives that reward team outcomes and don't create internal competition.
If you want a culture of integrity, hold leaders accountable to stated values and make consequences visible.
If you want a culture of customer focus, align every system, compensation, performance, and hiring around customer outcomes.
The culture you want requires systems that produce it. Without system alignment, you'll get the culture your current systems produce, regardless of what you state.
The Strategic Question
Before your next culture initiative, ask this: Which systems currently contradict our stated values?
Start there. Fix the contradiction.
The cultural work isn't workshops and posters. The culture work is systems alignment.
Get the systems right, and culture follows.
Leave the systems misaligned, and no amount of communication creates culture.
Culture is what systems produce. Build accordingly.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
