AI in Hospitality: What Hotel Staff and Guests Actually Want from Technology
Your front desk staff keeps going around the AI tools. Your guests keep asking to speak to a real person. These aren't bugs. They're features of human nature that your tech stack ignores.
Before your next technology investment, try The Hospitality AI Fit Test. Three questions that reveal whether a tool aligns with what both staff and guests actually value or whether you're about to spend money making everyone's experience worse.
The Service Paradox
Hospitality has always been about one thing: making people feel taken care of. Welcomed. Valued. The word "hospitality" literally means "friendly and generous treatment of guests."
So why does so much hospitality technology make people feel like they're interacting with a vending machine?
A recent J.D. Power study found that while technology satisfaction in hotels has increased, overall guest satisfaction has plateaued. The technology works. The experience isn't improving.
This tells us something important. Working technology and valued technology aren't the same thing.
What Hospitality Workers Value
Let's start with the staff. When we profile hospitality workers through the Valuegraphics Database, certain values consistently appear at the top.
Compassion (ranked 16th globally) shows up strongly in service-oriented professions. These are people who chose hospitality because they genuinely care about making others comfortable. AI that removes their ability to express compassion feels like it's taking away the best part of the job.
Relationships (ranked 2nd) are everywhere. Hospitality workers often value the connections they make with guests, the regulars, the stories, and the human moments. Automation that eliminates these touchpoints doesn't feel like efficiency. It feels like a loss.
Service to Others (ranked 42nd globally but much higher in hospitality profiles) defines professional identity. When AI handles the service, what's left?
What Guests Value
Guest profiles tell a related but different story.
Experiences (ranked 14th) bring people to hotels in the first place. They're not buying a room. They're buying an experience. AI that makes the experience feel transactional works against the very reason they came.
Belonging (ranked 4th) is what separates a great hotel from a good one. Guests want to feel like they fit. Like, they're welcome. Like they matter. Technology that creates distance between guest and staff erodes belonging.
Security (ranked 20th) shows up in interesting ways. Guests want to know someone is looking out for them. A human someone. AI that handles problems impersonally can trigger anxiety even when it handles them correctly.
The Hospitality AI Fit Test
Three questions for any technology you're considering:
1. Does this tool help staff express Compassion, or replace it?
Good: AI that gives front desk staff instant access to guest preferences so they can personalize interactions.
Bad: AI that handles guest interactions entirely, removing staff from the equation.
The test is simple. After this tool is implemented, will staff have more or fewer opportunities to show they care?
2. Does this tool create or destroy Belonging moments?
Good: Technology that recognizes returning guests and alerts staff to welcome them personally.
Bad: Kiosks that process guests without eye contact or human acknowledgment.
Belonging happens between humans. Technology should facilitate those moments, not eliminate them.
3. Does this tool increase felt Security or introduce friction?
Good: AI that identifies potential issues before they become problems, enabling staff to proactively help.
Bad: Chatbots that create loops of frustration when guests just want to talk to someone.
When guests feel unheard, they feel unsafe. The goal is always to make connections easier, not harder.
Where AI Actually Helps
The hospitality organizations getting AI right are using it to enhance human capacity, not replace human contact.
AI handles the invisible work of inventory optimization, dynamic pricing, predictive maintenance, and staff scheduling. Guests never interact with these systems directly. They just notice that things run smoothly.
For guest-facing applications, the best uses augment staff rather than replacing them. A concierge with AI-powered knowledge of local restaurants, events, and availability is more valuable than a concierge without it. The guest still gets the human interaction. It just got better.
The worst uses are the ones that create frustration for guests or remove meaning for staff. And you'd be amazed at how many technology investments fall into this category.
The Question Nobody's Asking
Here's what I think hospitality organizations should be asking before any AI investment: Will this make the experience more human or less human?
Not faster. Not more efficient. More human.
Because faster and more efficient are only valuable if they serve the real goal. And the real goal in hospitality is always human connection.
Technology is a tool. Connection is the job.
Don't confuse them.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
