The Science of Motivation: Why Incentives Backfire and Values Work
Your bonus structure is generous. Your recognition programs are elaborate. Your carrots and sticks are carefully designed. And somehow, the people you most want to motivate remain stubbornly unresponsive while the behaviors you're trying to encourage actually decline.
Here's what motivation science actually shows: The Values-Based Motivation Model. It explains why external incentives often backfire and how connecting work to values creates the intrinsic motivation that actually drives performance.
The Incentive Paradox
Research on motivation has produced surprising findings. External rewards often reduce motivation for the very behaviors they're designed to encourage. The effect is consistent across studies and surprisingly powerful.
The explanation is that external incentives can crowd out intrinsic motivation. When people are paid for something they were doing because they found it meaningful, the payment reframes the activity as transactional rather than purposeful.
"I'm doing this because it matters" becomes "I'm doing this because I'm paid to."
The second motivation is weaker and disappears when the incentive disappears.
What Actually Motivates
The Valuegraphics Database tracks 56 values that drive human behavior across a million surveys globally. When we examine motivation, it becomes clear that sustainable performance flows from values alignment, not from incentive design.
Personal Growth (ranked 6th at 51%) creates motivation when people see work as developing them into who they want to become.
Belonging (ranked 4th at 56%) creates motivation when people feel part of something larger than their individual effort.
Service to Others (ranked 42nd globally but higher in many professions) creates motivation when work helps people employees genuinely care about.
Personal Responsibility (ranked 36th at 18%) creates motivation when people own outcomes and take pride in what they deliver.
Respect (ranked 8th at 48%) creates motivation when people feel their contribution is valued by people they respect.
The Values-Based Motivation Model
Three principles for creating motivation that lasts:
Principle 1: Connect work to growth, not just output.
People who value Personal Growth are motivated by becoming more capable. Work that develops them is inherently motivating.
Connect work to growth through:
- Framing challenges as development opportunities
- Showing how current work builds toward future capabilities
- Creating visibility into the learning embedded in the work
- Celebrating growth, not just achievement
The question to ask: "How does this work help this person become who they want to become?"
When people see work as growth, they don't need external motivation. The motivation is the growth itself.
Principle 2: Create belonging to something that matters.
People who value Belonging is motivated by feeling part of something. Isolated tasks for personal gain don't engage this value.
Create belonging through:
- Building team identity around a shared mission
- Making collective success visible and celebrated
- Creating genuine community, not just collaboration
- Connecting individual contributions to team outcomes
The question to ask is, "Does this person feel they're part of something, or do they feel like an individual contributor who happens to report here?"
Belonging creates investment that incentives can't purchase. People work harder for communities they're part of than for employers who pay them.
Principle 3: Connect work to service, not just completion
People who value Service to Others are motivated by helping. Showing how work serves real people engages this value directly.
Connect work to service through:
- Making the human impact of work visible
- Sharing stories of how work helped actual people
- Creating a direct connection to those being served when possible
- Framing metrics in human terms, not just business terms
The question to ask: "Does this person understand who their work helps and how?"
When people see their work serving others, motivation flows from the impact, not from the compensation.
Why Incentives Backfire
Incentives backfire when they undermine the values-based motivation that was already present.
The scenario: An employee finds work meaningful because it helps customers (Service to Others). A bonus is introduced for customer satisfaction scores.
Expected result: employee tries harder because of the bonus.
Actual result: Employee's motivation shifts from genuine care to score optimization. Gaming behaviors emerge. Authentic service declines. When the bonus is modified or removed, motivation drops below baseline.
The incentive crowded out the intrinsic motivation that was working.
The Role of External Rewards
This doesn't mean all external rewards are harmful. The key is how they're positioned.
Harmful rewards: "Do X, get Y." Transactional. Creates expectations and gaming.
Helpful rewards: Unexpected recognition for values-aligned behavior. "I noticed you went above and beyond for that customer. Here's something to say thanks."
The difference is whether the reward replaces intrinsic motivation or acknowledges it.
Unexpected recognition for values-consistent behavior strengthens the values connection. Expected incentives for behavior metrics weaken it.
Diagnosing Motivation Issues
When motivation is low, ask, "Which values are disconnected?"
If Personal Growth is disconnected, the work feels like a dead end. Create development visibility.
If Belonging is disconnected, the person feels isolated. Build team connection.
If Service to Others is disconnected, the impact feels invisible. Show who the work helps.
If Personal Responsibility is disconnected, the person feels like a cog. Create ownership.
If Respect is disconnected, the contribution feels unvalued. Demonstrate genuine recognition.
The diagnosis points to the fix. Throwing incentives at values disconnection makes it worse, not better.
The Strategic Question
Before your next incentive design, ask this: What values-based motivation already exists that this incentive might undermine?
Protect and enhance intrinsic motivation before adding external motivation.
Connect work to growth, belonging, service, responsibility, and respect.
Then use external rewards sparingly as recognition, not as a motivation mechanism.
The motivation that works isn't purchased. It's created through values alignment.
Build that alignment. The motivation follows.
Remember: if you know what people value, you can change what happens next.
Download free tools, data, and reports at www.davidallisoninc.com/resources
Want to know What Matters Most to the people you need to inspire?
Download free guides and resources.
Use the free Valueprint Finder to see how your values compare.
Find out why people call David “The Values Guy.”
Search the blog library for ways to put values to work for you.
